Side-by-side (stockade, or dog ear when the tops are cut) sets each cedar picket edge to edge. Board-on-board overlaps the pickets so there is no line of sight through the fence. This guide compares the two on cost, lumber, gaps, wind, the neighbor's side and Dallas rules, with every number sourced. For how we build fences, see our page on cedar fence installation in Dallas.
Board on board vs side by side fence cost in Dallas
Board-on-board costs more than side-by-side in every source we checked. Fixr's 150 ft figures work out to about $21 to $45 a foot for board-on-board against $15 to $30 for dog ear (our arithmetic on Fixr's figures, 2025), and Ergeon's completed projects put board-on-board at $51 to $82 a foot against $41 to $68 for dog-ear (Ergeon wood fence page, read November 2026).
Ergeon says board-on-board is its most popular upgrade and runs roughly 40% more than a basic dog-ear (Ergeon wood fence page). Its older January 2025 guide gives a much lower $20 to $40 a foot, materials and installation (Ergeon, 2025). Both figures come from Ergeon, so we show both.
| Source | Side-by-side / dog ear, per ft | Board-on-board, per ft |
|---|---|---|
| Fixr privacy fence guide (Jan 2025, national), 150 ft totals divided by 150 (our arithmetic) | Dog ear about $15 to $30 | About $21 to $45 |
| Fixr wood fence guide (Jan 2025, national) | Stockade $15 to $20 installed | Not listed separately (Fixr's shadowbox is $17 to $35) |
| Ergeon wood fence page (undated, read Nov 2026) | Dog-ear / nail-up $41 to $68 installed | Board-on-board (picture frame) $51 to $82 installed |
| Ergeon board-on-board guide (Jan 2025) | Not listed | $20 to $40, materials and installation |
The gap is about $6 to $15 a foot on Fixr's figures and $10 to $14 on Ergeon's (our arithmetic on each source's figures). The sources disagree widely on the base price (Ergeon's current per-foot figures run about 1.8 to 2.7 times Fixr's, our arithmetic on each source's figures), so don't average them. Ergeon lists Dallas among its service cities (Ergeon wood fence page), and its cost guide says Southern markets average $44 a foot in its regional comparison (Ergeon, July 2026), but no source we could open gives a Dallas-only price for either style. Archetex gives a written price after a free site visit.
What the difference adds up to on a 150 ft Dallas backyard
On a 150 ft run, board-on-board adds roughly $900 to $2,250 on Fixr's figures, or $1,500 to $2,100 on Ergeon's (our arithmetic on each source's figures).
| Source | Side-by-side / dog ear, 150 ft | Board-on-board, 150 ft | Extra for board-on-board |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixr 150 ft table (Jan 2025) | Dog ear $2,250 to $4,500; stockade $2,250 to $4,000 | $3,150 to $6,750 | About $900 to $2,250 vs dog ear (low vs low, high vs high) |
| Ergeon completed projects, times 150 (our arithmetic) | Dog-ear $6,150 to $10,200 | $7,650 to $12,300 | About $1,500 to $2,100 |
| Ergeon board-on-board guide, times 150 (our arithmetic) | Not listed | $3,000 to $6,000 | Not available |
These totals cover the fence line only. Gates, tear-out and kickboards are covered in what a cedar fence costs in Dallas rather than repeat them here. Archetex gives a written price after a free site visit.
2026 Dallas Texas cedar fence installation cost per linear foot: materials and labor by style
The cedar fence prices we could check run from $15 to $70 a foot installed, and the style moves the price more than the wood does. Fixr puts installed western red cedar fencing at $15 to $30 a foot, with $5 to $15 of that in material (Fixr, 2025). Ergeon's cedar page puts a cedar fence at $41 to $70 a foot installed, with a median of about $52, and says style is the bigger cost driver, with board-on-board and horizontal costing more (Ergeon cedar page, read November 2026).
Ergeon says species changes the price by only about $5 a foot (Ergeon wood fence page), while Fixr puts stockade materials at $5 to $10 a foot and shadowbox at $7 to $15 (Fixr, 2025). For height, species and add-ons, see what a cedar fence costs in Dallas. Archetex gives a written price after a free site visit.
How many boards each style needs (the lumber math)
An 8 ft section takes about 18 side-by-side pickets but 24 board-on-board pickets, roughly a third more wood (our arithmetic on Omni Calculator's formula). Omni's formula is fence length minus picket width, divided by picket width minus overlap, plus one, rounded up. With 5½ inch pickets and a 1½ inch overlap that is 24 pickets per 8 ft section; with 3½ inch pickets and a 1 inch overlap, 38 (Omni Calculator, 2024).
- Side-by-side, 5½ inch pickets edge to edge in a 96 inch section: 96 divided by 5.5 is 17.5, so 18 pickets (our arithmetic; Omni's formula with no overlap gives the same).
- Board-on-board, 5½ inch pickets with a 1½ inch overlap: 24 pickets (Omni Calculator).
- A 150 ft fence is about 19 sections of 8 ft (150 divided by 8 is 18.75, rounded up), so roughly 342 pickets side-by-side vs 456 board-on-board (our arithmetic, before any waste).
How much overlap is enough? Omni says to use an overlap at least twice the expected shrinkage. Its worst case for shrinkage is 12% of the picket width, so its rule of thumb is an overlap of 24% of the width, about 1.3 inches on a 5½ inch picket (Omni Calculator, 2024).
Layouts vary. Ergeon describes one common layout as 6 inch boards with 1½ inch gaps, covered by a second layer of 4 inch boards (Ergeon, 2025), and says pickets come in 4 or 6 inch widths on panels most commonly 8 ft wide (Ergeon wood fence page). Ask any builder to write the picket width and overlap on the quote.
Privacy: why side-by-side gaps open as cedar dries
Side-by-side boards butt edge to edge, so when each one shrinks, small gaps show; board-on-board's overlap covers them. Fixr says wood can shrink about ⅛ to ¼ inch as it dries after installation, leaving minor gaps (Fixr, 2025).
To show what that means on one section: 18 side-by-side pickets each shrinking ⅛ inch adds up to about 2¼ inches of open gaps across 8 ft, and at ¼ inch each it is about 4½ inches. That is illustrative arithmetic on Fixr's range, not a measurement.
Top Rail Fence rates side-by-side at 98 to 99% privacy, with hairline gaps over time, and calls board-on-board's staggered rows 100% privacy (Top Rail Fence, February 2025). Ergeon says board-on-board's overlap leaves no gaps even as the wood expands and contracts (Ergeon wood fence page). Ergeon also says cedar shrinks far less than pine (Ergeon cedar page), but less shrinkage is still some shrinkage.
Wind in North Texas storms: which style holds up, and why posts matter more
Both styles are solid, so both catch the full wind; what decides whether a fence stays up is mostly the posts, not the board pattern. Trex Fencing's guidance says privacy fences block more wind because there are no spaces, but they tend to act as a sail and may be damaged by strong winds, and wood fencing may break, especially with a 4x4 post (Trex Fencing, 2021).
Severe thunderstorm winds are 58 mph or greater (Southern Climate Impacts Planning Program, 2026), and in April 2020 gusts of up to 70 mph left one Frisco neighborhood "littered with downed fences" (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth, 2020).
Top Rail's North Dallas office says board-on-board cedar resists North Texas storm wind (Top Rail Fence North Dallas, 2025). That is a contractor's claim, and Top Rail's own comparison table gives board-on-board and solid privacy fences "Low" airflow (Top Rail Fence, February 2025). The style sources say lets wind through is shadowbox, which gives up full privacy.
Ergeon's advice for windy sites is framing: build 6 ft panels instead of the common 8 ft. It says posts are typically 4x4 pressure-treated pine set 2 to 4 ft deep in cement, and calls wood pickets on steel posts "a practical hybrid for windy sites and longer runs" (Ergeon wood fence page). The ground matters too: the Texas Water Development Board says Houston Black clay, found on about 1.5 million acres of the Blackland Prairie that runs from north of Dallas to San Antonio, shrinks and swells markedly with changes in moisture (Texas Water Development Board).
Steel posts vs wood posts
Fixr says metal fence posts cost $10 to $60 installed, are unlikely to rot and can withstand strong winds (Fixr, 2025). One North Dallas company, Top Rail Fence, shows a board-on-board job on 2⅜ inch metal posts and lists its own standard as steel posts set 36 inches deep in concrete (Top Rail Fence North Dallas). Those are one company's specs, not a city code. Archetex sets its cedar fences on galvanized steel posts, whichever board pattern you choose.
Which side faces the neighbor? The "good neighbor" look
On a typical side-by-side fence one side shows the picket faces and the other shows the rails; board-on-board and shadowbox can be built to look finished from both sides, so ask how yours will be built. Trex Fencing says the side that reveals the cross-rails, and in some cases metal posts, is usually called the "ugly side," and most owners face it inward, though sometimes it faces the neighbor (Trex Fencing, 2021).
Ergeon says board-on-board looks finished from both sides and calls shadowbox "a neighbor-friendly compromise" (Ergeon wood and cedar pages). Top Rail's North Dallas office advises facing the finished side toward the neighbor's property (Top Rail Fence North Dallas, January 2026). But Ergeon describes one layout with pickets on alternating sides of the rails and another with two overlapping layers attached to the rails, which can leave the rails showing on one side. Ask whether the rails will show on your side or the neighbor's. If you are sharing the cost with a neighbor, see fence permits and who pays for a shared fence in Texas.
Shadowbox vs board-on-board: not the same fence
Shadowbox spaces its alternating pickets 2 to 4 inches apart for airflow, so it is semi-private; board-on-board overlaps them with no gaps. Top Rail Fence says shadowbox is "great for reducing wind load" and dries faster after rain (Top Rail Fence, February 2025).
The names get mixed up. Fixr says shadow box is "sometimes called a board-on-board fence" and prices it at $17 to $35 a foot installed (Fixr, 2025), so check the picket spacing or overlap written on any quote. If you want a different look altogether, a horizontal cedar fence is another option, and Ergeon lists horizontal at $63 to $129 a foot (Ergeon wood fence page).
Lifespan and staining for each style
Cedar is quoted at 15 to 30 years, and no source we found shows one board pattern outlasting the other. Ergeon's cedar page says 15 to 30 years and its wood fence page says 15 to 20 (Ergeon). Fixr says shadowbox fences, mostly red cedar and treated pine, need regular treatment and can "last only around five to ten years" (Fixr, 2025).
Staining estimates conflict too: Fixr puts staining a privacy fence at $7 to $13.50 a linear foot (Fixr, 2025), while Ergeon says stain, seal or paint add-ons cost about $1 to $4 each per linear foot (Ergeon, July 2026). We found no source comparing staining cost by style.
Dallas fence permits, height rules and HOA style rules
Dallas needs a permit for a fence over 6 ft (over 4 ft in a front yard), caps fences at 9 ft, and keeps solid front-yard fences 5 ft back from the front lot line; HOAs may regulate fence type under Texas law. The board pattern itself doesn't change the permit. Height and location do.
- Dallas: checklist 26-001 (June 2026) requires a permit over 4 ft in a front yard or 6 ft elsewhere, sets a 9 ft maximum, and asks for a panel drawing showing height, materials and "openness" (City of Dallas, 2026).
- Dallas front yards: under Ordinance 30198, in single-family districts a panel less than 50% open may not be within 5 ft of the front lot line, with fines up to $2,000 (City of Dallas, 2016). Both styles are solid, so under the ordinance's wording that applies to either. Confirm with the city.
- Frisco: permits are required for all fences except repairing or replacing up to two sections or 16 ft; rear and side fences can be up to 8 ft (City of Frisco).
- HOAs: Texas Property Code §202.023 says an HOA can't ban a perimeter fence, but it may regulate the type of fencing an owner installs. Check your HOA's guidelines before you pick a style.
Plano and McKinney rules are in our permit guide linked above. Local notes are on our Dallas and Frisco pages.
Which one should you choose?
Pick side-by-side if budget matters most and small gaps are acceptable; pick board-on-board if you want no gaps and a better look from the neighbor's side, and plan the posts well either way.
- Side-by-side: the lowest price. Fixr names 6 ft stockade cedar as the least expensive privacy fence (Fixr, 2025).
- Board-on-board: full privacy that stays full as the cedar dries, for about a third more boards.
- Shadowbox: airflow over a full screen.
- Either solid style: ask about post type, spacing and depth.
Best fence companies in Dallas TX: reviews, reputation and what to check in 2026
Pick a company with recent Google reviews you can read and a written quote that lists the style, picket width and overlap, post type and depth, gates, tear-out, stain and who pulls the permit.
Archetex Outdoor Design Co. builds cedar privacy, board-on-board, horizontal and ranch fences on galvanized steel posts, laid out to the property's real lines and grade. You can see finished fences on our work page, or ask for a free site visit and a written price.

